Please provide a link to the repo so I can see what youāre decentralising. I believe a link to your init.yaml file is needed for the syndication period to start.
Thanks @rem.codes. Itās important to be able to validated that the init.yaml hasnāt been modified inbetween the announcement and the launch proposal (as that invalidates the syndication period). In this case there was no syndication period, but assuming the proposer wanted to follow established standards for acceptable SNS proposals, how would a reviewer take a snapshot of the initialisation config to confirm it isnāt changed later? An init.yaml is very useful for this.
The tokenomics analyzer also expects an init.yaml file or an link to a git repo containing one.
TLDR: This SNS launch doesnāt comply with established best practices put forward by DFINITY. Personally I think these are important, particularly the syndication period which was non-existent in this case.
There are no dapp canisters in this particular attempt. Related reading (prior attempt).
You may wish to follow the CO.DELTA known neuron if you found this analysis helpful.
CO.DELTA ā³
Weāre a verifiably decentralised collective who review IC deltas (changes applied by NNS proposals). We follow a common code:
Look: We observe the details and context of NNS proposals
Test: We test and verify the claims made by those proposals
Automate: We automate as much as possible by building increasingly sophisticated tools that streamline and strengthen the reviewal process.
Every vote cast by CO.DELTA is the result of consensus among diligent, skilled and experienced team members acting independently. The CO.DELTA neuron follows the vote of D-QUORUM on NNS topics that the CO.DELTA team does not handle directly. You can therefore follow CO.DELTA on all topics and rely on the highest quality of vote.
Originally there was a 2 week review period proposed by toolkit in which the proposal could be reviewed on toolkit itself before pushing forward the SNS proposal.
There might have been something unclear on the SNS creation flow which caused the proposal to go out immediately.
Regarding the analyzer, this is also present on the SNS review page on toolkit.
following up on a lot of dancing around this over the years, and give holders a fun software suite to manage and govern.
as well as be a nimble defi environment. Itās hard to be nimble with a large dao like sneed or taco, tendies ticker tendyās dao can nimbly work with ntns tooling and create some fun implementations. Perhaps the dao would want to set up a series of trading vectors attached to neurons? Maybe the dao would like to stake tokens and govern on the nns?
But we wonāt know until it happens.
if you look at the tokenomics, itās a relatively fair launch with the allocation to cover the 88,000 icrc1 tendies.
Also, you yourself donāt have to participate in the sns launchpad itself, just vote to move it along.
I realized I didnāt give this the proper review it deserves. Apologies @Henry_Suso Iām new at this. Iām not a granted reviewer but Iāll do my best. These may not be the current standards for review, but I think theyāre as good as any.
No fake apartments that donāt exist. No rental cars that donāt even feed money back to the token or use ICP. No infinite canister spam clogging up subnets for non-existent users. No neurons fund A chicken tender on the internet computer.
Conclusion: Adopt.
No one needs to buy chicken tendies if they donāt want to. But this SNS is 100% honest about what it is. Itās Chicken Tendies on the IC, nothing more, nothing less. Iām more a burger guy myself. To each his own.
I motion 2nd. Of non grant reviewer accepting of proposal. Try hard or hardly try. Aim small miss small. El patriot Gibson. & giggles brought mainstream adoption to the internet. ARRR DOUBLE YOU WAZE brought the dot com bubble. Gamers waste time and money doing useless in a fake world. I dunno wtf TENDIES isā¦ it dies hard or pumps hard. Depends on teddies community. Not some try hard fugazi tryna onboard jeetz tryna dump soon as they grt a chanceā¦.. maybe tendies community can so some magic and some whale with pull will multiply it to the moon for no other reason than cuz theyāre bored.
No fake apartments that donāt exist.
& giggles brought mainstream adoption to the internet. ARRR DOUBLE YOU WAZE brought the dot com bubble. Gamers waste time and money doing useless