Seed Round Access

Because which ICP account belongs to a given neuron is not public information. You need to be the controller or you need to be one of the configured hotkeys of the neuron to be able to see it.

@timo Thank you for all the answers!! Really, it is extremely helpful :slight_smile:
I will try dissolve my first of the 49 neurons, to see what comes out.

Great. Is there documentation on this, or will that only be available one Ledger company pushes the update?

I’ve noticed they’ve been slow over the past month during the holidays pushing all updates.

Now when I access one of my neurons, I can see Locked time, Amount staked, Voting power and Maturity.
As I understand, my current reward is equal to the Maturity times the staked amount. Is that correct?

Any news on this? Claiming is not possible yet?

1 Like

Yes, that’s correct.

No update here. The code was merged here: Support for claim neuron and join community fund by leongb · Pull Request #140 · Zondax/ledger-icp · GitHub and is part of release v2.0.0 from here: Releases · Zondax/ledger-icp · GitHub
That release is unfortunately still under review by Ledger since Dec 20, 2021. Timeline is under Ledger’s control.

So there is already v2.0.2 but I don’t see any option to claim seed neurons.

Where do you see v2.0.2? Not in Ledger’s app store, or? I only see v1.0.3 there.

1 Like

I think there is a confusion between the version of the hardwallet firmware and the version of the ICP app, in your dialogue.

1 Like

I confused the hw firmware and the icp app version.

Are we still waiting for ledger update?

yup :frowning: ledger aren’t the best at prioritising

Ledger has updated lots of other apps in this timeframe.

1 Like

Hi ! Any news on anything related to claiming seed neurons in a user-friendly way via Ledger?
This is a bit of a bad look, are we still waiting for approval from Ledger Inc?

1 Like

Let me ping folks working with ledger to find out.

1 Like

Unfortunately no news. The update has been sitting with Ledger for months and months now.

1 Like

Ledger has approved lots of other apps for much smaller chains recently.

ICP needs to put forth some effort to have Ledger approve this. Interact with a reputable company like Zondax who can help you move the needle on getting approved.

The slowness and lack of any urgency to get this done is really disheartening. Ledger is not to blame here.

I think that’s fair criticism and it does hint that our routine of pinging and asking Ledger and Zondax is not enough. It’s healthy to see what (in the realm of what we have control of) can improve at.

It’s clear we should look at what we can do differently.

I do not work with zondax and ledger, but I think it’s fair we should iterate to see what we can do differently. Let me ping some folks.

2 Likes

I partially agree, but its not Dfinity’s fault for sure, if Ledger approved the app to be listed on its platform they should guarantee updates are delivered in a timely manner, if they don’t believe it’s worth the hassle the app should’t have been listed in the first place. Dfinity has its own business to care about, they shouldn’t be losing time making sure another company does its job.

1 Like

As you may know, we are working with Zondax; they programmed the IC application for the Ledger devices and are also interacting with Ledger to get the update in. Ledger even communicated planned dates for publishing the update to us, it just never materialized anyway.

1 Like