I concur that this is probably what happened.
Yes, I mentioned this earlier:
My main claim is that all fields define month the same. I could not find any evidence to the contrary.
2 Likes
For the track record, I get the same duration when I simulate submitting the SNS.yaml of DOGMI and ICVC with proposals.network locally as what was proposed on the mainnet. Sounds good.
Hi everyone,
I will soon be proposing to turn Juno into a DAO using the SNS framework. Since there is still some uncertainty regarding this specific duration issue, I would appreciate it if one of the foundation NNS developers participating in this thread could run my SNS YAML file with your tooling and confirm that you’re getting the same duration as I do with proposals.network.
After disabling the neuron funds and removing the dapp canisters from the YAML file, this is the payload of the Create Service Nervous System proposal that I am able to generate.
{
"url": "https://juno.build",
"governanceParameters": {
"neuronMaximumDissolveDelayBonus": {
"basisPoints": "7500"
},
"neuronMaximumAgeForAgeBonus": {
"seconds": "94672800"
},
"neuronMaximumDissolveDelay": {
"seconds": "94672800"
},
"neuronMinimumDissolveDelayToVote": {
"seconds": "15780096"
},
"neuronMaximumAgeBonus": {
"basisPoints": "2500"
},
"neuronMinimumStake": {
"e8s": "10000000000"
},
"proposalWaitForQuietDeadlineIncrease": {
"seconds": "86400"
},
"proposalInitialVotingPeriod": {
"seconds": "259200"
},
"proposalRejectionFee": {
"e8s": "10000000000"
},
"votingRewardParameters": {
"rewardRateTransitionDuration": {
"seconds": "31557600"
},
"initialRewardRate": {
"basisPoints": "150"
},
"finalRewardRate": {
"basisPoints": "150"
}
}
},
"fallbackControllerPrincipalIds": [
"tpv2w-kr3vj-a3mac-wivgj-5mwwr-egoxz-vxdpg-oqul5-3oygd-derik-jqe",
"miso6-cu5ju-xcxwf-v2upq-mn32j-sn7lf-7mgiq-rh5ec-olmvw-a6z54-pqe"
],
"logo": {
"base64Encoding": "...gg=="
},
"tokenName": "Juno Build"
},
"description": "Juno is a blockchain-as-a-service platform that equips developers with all the essential tools to create Web3 applications, making it as easy as developing with Web2 cloud services. It offers a growing number of features, including authentication, data and file storage, hosting, serverless functions, and on-chain analytics.",
"dappCanisters": [],
"swapParameters": {
"minimumParticipants": "100",
"duration": {
"seconds": "1209600"
},
"neuronBasketConstructionParameters": {
"dissolveDelayInterval": {
"seconds": "15780096"
},
"count": "5"
},
"confirmationText": "I confirm my understanding of the responsibilities and risks associated with participating in this token swap and that I am not a resident of any of the excluded countries.\n",
"maximumParticipantIcp": {
"e8s": "20000000000000"
},
"neuronsFundInvestmentIcp": undefined,
"minimumIcp": undefined,
"minimumParticipantIcp": {
"e8s": "1000000000"
},
"startTime": undefined,
"maximumIcp": undefined,
"restrictedCountries": {
"isoCodes": [
"AF",
"BY",
"BA",
"BI",
"CF",
"KP",
"CD",
"IR",
"IQ",
"LB",
"LY",
"ML",
"ME",
"MM",
"NI",
"RU",
"RS",
"SO",
"SD",
"SY",
"UA",
"VE",
"YE",
"ZW"
]
},
"maxDirectParticipationIcp": {
"e8s": "35000000000000"
},
"minDirectParticipationIcp": {
"e8s": "20000000000000"
},
"neuronsFundParticipation": false
},
"initialTokenDistribution": {
"treasuryDistribution": {
"total": {
"e8s": "5000000000000000"
}
},
"developerDistribution": {
"developerNeurons": [
{
"controller": "k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe",
"dissolveDelay": {
"seconds": "63115200"
},
"memo": "0",
"vestingPeriod": {
"seconds": "157788000"
},
"stake": {
"e8s": "400000000000000"
}
},
{
"controller": "k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe",
"dissolveDelay": {
"seconds": "47340288"
},
"memo": "1",
"vestingPeriod": {
"seconds": "94672800"
},
"stake": {
"e8s": "400000000000000"
}
},
{
"controller": "k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe",
"dissolveDelay": {
"seconds": "31557600"
},
"memo": "2",
"vestingPeriod": {
"seconds": "63115200"
},
"stake": {
"e8s": "400000000000000"
}
},
{
"controller": "k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe",
"dissolveDelay": {
"seconds": "23670144"
},
"memo": "3",
"vestingPeriod": {
"seconds": "47340288"
},
"stake": {
"e8s": "400000000000000"
}
},
{
"controller": "k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe",
"dissolveDelay": {
"seconds": "15780096"
},
"memo": "4",
"vestingPeriod": {
"seconds": "31557600"
},
"stake": {
"e8s": "400000000000000"
}
}
]
},
"swapDistribution": {
"total": {
"e8s": "3000000000000000"
}
}
}
}
Thanks in advance for your feedback.
Given that I’m planning to create the proposal soon, up.
There were few adjustements in the sns_init.yaml file (as communicated in the related thread), so here is the up-to-date content of the generated Create Service Nervous System proposal (minus logo).
{
"url": "https://juno.build",
"governanceParameters": {
"neuronMaximumDissolveDelayBonus": {
"basisPoints": "7500"
},
"neuronMaximumAgeForAgeBonus": {
"seconds": "94672800"
},
"neuronMaximumDissolveDelay": {
"seconds": "94672800"
},
"neuronMinimumDissolveDelayToVote": {
"seconds": "15780096"
},
"neuronMaximumAgeBonus": {
"basisPoints": "2500"
},
"neuronMinimumStake": {
"e8s": "1000000000"
},
"proposalWaitForQuietDeadlineIncrease": {
"seconds": "86400"
},
"proposalInitialVotingPeriod": {
"seconds": "259200"
},
"proposalRejectionFee": {
"e8s": "10000000000"
},
"votingRewardParameters": {
"rewardRateTransitionDuration": {
"seconds": "31557600"
},
"initialRewardRate": {
"basisPoints": "150"
},
"finalRewardRate": {
"basisPoints": "150"
}
}
},
"fallbackControllerPrincipalIds": [
"tpv2w-kr3vj-a3mac-wivgj-5mwwr-egoxz-vxdpg-oqul5-3oygd-derik-jqe",
"miso6-cu5ju-xcxwf-v2upq-mn32j-sn7lf-7mgiq-rh5ec-olmvw-a6z54-pqe"
],
"logo": {
"base64Encoding": "...Jggg=="
},
"name": "Juno Build",
"ledgerParameters": {
"transactionFee": {
"e8s": "1000000"
},
"tokenSymbol": "JUNOBUILD",
"tokenLogo": {
"base64Encoding": "...Jggg=="
},
"tokenName": "Juno Build"
},
"description": "Juno is a blockchain-as-a-service platform that empowers developers to build decentralized apps efficiently. It offers a comprehensive toolkit to scaffold secure and efficient projects.",
"dappCanisters": [],
"swapParameters": {
"minimumParticipants": "1",
"duration": {
"seconds": "1209600"
},
"neuronBasketConstructionParameters": {
"dissolveDelayInterval": {
"seconds": "15780096"
},
"count": "5"
},
"confirmationText": "I confirm my understanding of the responsibilities and risks associated with participating in this token swap and that I am not a resident of any of the excluded countries.\n",
"maximumParticipantIcp": {
"e8s": "20000000000000"
},
"neuronsFundInvestmentIcp": undefined,
"minimumIcp": undefined,
"minimumParticipantIcp": {
"e8s": "100000000"
},
"startTime": undefined,
"maximumIcp": undefined,
"restrictedCountries": {
"isoCodes": [
"AF",
"BY",
"BA",
"BI",
"CF",
"KP",
"CD",
"IR",
"IQ",
"LB",
"LY",
"ML",
"ME",
"MM",
"NI",
"RU",
"RS",
"SO",
"SD",
"SY",
"UA",
"VE",
"YE",
"ZW"
]
},
"maxDirectParticipationIcp": {
"e8s": "35000000000000"
},
"minDirectParticipationIcp": {
"e8s": "20000000000000"
},
"neuronsFundParticipation": false
},
"initialTokenDistribution": {
"treasuryDistribution": {
"total": {
"e8s": "5000000000000000"
}
},
"developerDistribution": {
"developerNeurons": [
{
"controller": "k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe",
"dissolveDelay": {
"seconds": "63115200"
},
"memo": "0",
"vestingPeriod": {
"seconds": "157788000"
},
"stake": {
"e8s": "400000000000000"
}
},
{
"controller": "k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe",
"dissolveDelay": {
"seconds": "47340288"
},
"memo": "1",
"vestingPeriod": {
"seconds": "94672800"
},
"stake": {
"e8s": "400000000000000"
}
},
{
"controller": "k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe",
"dissolveDelay": {
"seconds": "31557600"
},
"memo": "2",
"vestingPeriod": {
"seconds": "63115200"
},
"stake": {
"e8s": "400000000000000"
}
},
{
"controller": "k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe",
"dissolveDelay": {
"seconds": "23670144"
},
"memo": "3",
"vestingPeriod": {
"seconds": "47340288"
},
"stake": {
"e8s": "400000000000000"
}
},
{
"controller": "k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe",
"dissolveDelay": {
"seconds": "15780096"
},
"memo": "4",
"vestingPeriod": {
"seconds": "31557600"
},
"stake": {
"e8s": "400000000000000"
}
}
]
},
"swapDistribution": {
"total": {
"e8s": "3000000000000000"
}
}
}
}
Hi @peterparker
I added one line println!("proposal = {:#?}", proposal); to the load_configuration_and_validate function of the propose subcommand of SNS CLI tool (bazel run //rs/sns/cli:sns -- propose --test-neuron-proposer) to see what proposal payload would be generated for your YAML file, and it seems that all time-related fields match those that you posted above (there were 18 such fields, right?)
Here’s the full payload I’ve got:
proposal = Proposal {
title: Some(
"NNS Proposal to create an SNS named 'Juno Build'",
),
summary: "",
url: "https://forum.dfinity.org/thread-where-this-sns-is-discussed",
action: Some(
CreateServiceNervousSystem(
CreateServiceNervousSystem {
name: Some(
"Juno Build",
),
description: Some(
"Juno is a blockchain-as-a-service platform that empowers developers to build decentralized apps efficiently. It offers a comprehensive toolkit to scaffold secure and efficient projects.",
),
url: Some(
"https://juno.build",
),
logo: Some(
Image {
base64_encoding: Some(
"data:image/png;base64,",
),
},
),
fallback_controller_principal_ids: [
tpv2w-kr3vj-a3mac-wivgj-5mwwr-egoxz-vxdpg-oqul5-3oygd-derik-jqe,
miso6-cu5ju-xcxwf-v2upq-mn32j-sn7lf-7mgiq-rh5ec-olmvw-a6z54-pqe,
],
dapp_canisters: [
Canister {
id: Some(
cokmz-oiaaa-aaaal-aby6q-cai,
),
},
Canister {
id: Some(
klbfr-lqaaa-aaaak-qbwsa-cai,
),
},
Canister {
id: Some(
fmkjf-bqaaa-aaaal-acpza-cai,
),
},
],
initial_token_distribution: Some(
InitialTokenDistribution {
developer_distribution: Some(
DeveloperDistribution {
developer_neurons: [
NeuronDistribution {
controller: Some(
k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe,
),
dissolve_delay: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
63115200,
),
},
),
memo: Some(
0,
),
stake: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
400000000000000,
),
},
),
vesting_period: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
157788000,
),
},
),
},
NeuronDistribution {
controller: Some(
k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe,
),
dissolve_delay: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
47340288,
),
},
),
memo: Some(
1,
),
stake: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
400000000000000,
),
},
),
vesting_period: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
94672800,
),
},
),
},
NeuronDistribution {
controller: Some(
k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe,
),
dissolve_delay: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
31557600,
),
},
),
memo: Some(
2,
),
stake: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
400000000000000,
),
},
),
vesting_period: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
63115200,
),
},
),
},
NeuronDistribution {
controller: Some(
k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe,
),
dissolve_delay: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
23670144,
),
},
),
memo: Some(
3,
),
stake: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
400000000000000,
),
},
),
vesting_period: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
47340288,
),
},
),
},
NeuronDistribution {
controller: Some(
k5nen-up7es-gfojt-3cbvu-ejeec-kjull-457tg-en2xi-ixjgm-vnxmv-tqe,
),
dissolve_delay: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
15780096,
),
},
),
memo: Some(
4,
),
stake: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
400000000000000,
),
},
),
vesting_period: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
31557600,
),
},
),
},
],
},
),
treasury_distribution: Some(
TreasuryDistribution {
total: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
5000000000000000,
),
},
),
},
),
swap_distribution: Some(
SwapDistribution {
total: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
3000000000000000,
),
},
),
},
),
},
),
swap_parameters: Some(
SwapParameters {
minimum_participants: Some(
100,
),
minimum_icp: None,
maximum_icp: None,
minimum_direct_participation_icp: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
20000000000000,
),
},
),
maximum_direct_participation_icp: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
35000000000000,
),
},
),
minimum_participant_icp: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
100000000,
),
},
),
maximum_participant_icp: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
20000000000000,
),
},
),
neuron_basket_construction_parameters: Some(
NeuronBasketConstructionParameters {
count: Some(
5,
),
dissolve_delay_interval: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
15780096,
),
},
),
},
),
confirmation_text: Some(
"I confirm my understanding of the responsibilities and risks associated with participating in this token swap and that I am not a resident of any of the excluded countries.\n",
),
restricted_countries: Some(
Countries {
iso_codes: [
"AF",
"BY",
"BA",
"BI",
"CF",
"KP",
"CD",
"IR",
"IQ",
"LB",
"LY",
"ML",
"ME",
"MM",
"NI",
"RU",
"RS",
"SO",
"SD",
"SY",
"UA",
"VE",
"YE",
"ZW",
],
},
),
start_time: None,
duration: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
1209600,
),
},
),
neurons_fund_investment_icp: None,
neurons_fund_participation: Some(
true,
),
},
),
ledger_parameters: Some(
LedgerParameters {
transaction_fee: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
1000000,
),
},
),
token_name: Some(
"Juno Build",
),
token_symbol: Some(
"JUNOBUILD",
),
token_logo: Some(
Image {
base64_encoding: Some(
"data:image/png;base64,",
),
},
),
},
),
governance_parameters: Some(
GovernanceParameters {
proposal_rejection_fee: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
10000000000,
),
},
),
proposal_initial_voting_period: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
259200,
),
},
),
proposal_wait_for_quiet_deadline_increase: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
86400,
),
},
),
neuron_minimum_stake: Some(
Tokens {
e8s: Some(
1000000000,
),
},
),
neuron_minimum_dissolve_delay_to_vote: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
15780096,
),
},
),
neuron_maximum_dissolve_delay: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
94672800,
),
},
),
neuron_maximum_dissolve_delay_bonus: Some(
Percentage {
basis_points: Some(
7500,
),
},
),
neuron_maximum_age_for_age_bonus: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
94672800,
),
},
),
neuron_maximum_age_bonus: Some(
Percentage {
basis_points: Some(
2500,
),
},
),
voting_reward_parameters: Some(
VotingRewardParameters {
initial_reward_rate: Some(
Percentage {
basis_points: Some(
150,
),
},
),
final_reward_rate: Some(
Percentage {
basis_points: Some(
150,
),
},
),
reward_rate_transition_duration: Some(
Duration {
seconds: Some(
31557600,
),
},
),
},
),
},
),
},
),
),
}
Hope this helps.
1 Like
I manually compared all the fields of the payload you got with the ones I generated, and they all matched. Therefore, I’m confident that this issue is resolved, and I’ll be able to proceed with submitting Juno’s proposal. Thanks a lot for your help!
1 Like