Proposals 135774-135799, 135804-135806, 135822, 135830, 135831 Review | Louise - Aviate Labs
Hi Community,
This is the review for the recent batch of proposals submitted to remove Node Providers (see below) from the network.
While there is no standard criteria for assessing whether a Node Provider should be removed, these proposals can be interpreted as a way to clean up the registry and identifying which Node Providers were onboarded prior to any formal verification process established, and who have no intention of continuing.
Aviate Labs supports maintaining a transparent transparent registry and effective verification process for Node Providers on the IC. Thus, we will adopt the proposals removing the NPs that:
- Have no active nodes AND
- Have no forum activity OR
- Fail to meet the current verification standards set by the community - having a signed self declaration and proof of identity document (and the corresponding hashes) uploaded to the NP’s self declarations page listed on this page on the IC Wiki.
For the Node Providers listed in the proposals we will vote to adopt (supporting their removal from the network), if you still intend to remain a Node Provider, please submit a new proposal with the correct documentation. This will allow your application to go through the established community criteria checks.
For the proposals that Aviate Labs has voted to reject, these Node Providers have:
- Followed the established community processes and standards, even if their forum activity is minimal. It is reasonable for new applicants to create an account solely for submitting forum posts to endorse their proposals, as for many, Node Providing was probably how they were introduced to the ecosystem. As some applications did not progress further due to target topology constraints, it is understandable that their forum engagement then remains limited to those posts. Concretely, I have verified that they have a self declaration and proof of identity document uploaded as well as the corresponding hashes uploaded to the right page in the IC Wiki. This is inline with the checks the current Known Neuron Grant recipients do for this specific proposal type.
- Active nodes assigned to their NP ID
For a full breakdown of how Aviate Labs will vote on the proposals mentioned, please see the end of this post.
| Proposal | Vote | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 135774 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135775 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135776 | REJECT | Complies with current verifications standards set by the community and followed by reviewers |
| 135777 | REJECT | Complies with current verifications standards set by the community and followed by reviewers |
| 135778 | REJECT | Complies with current verifications standards set by the community and followed by reviewers |
| 135779 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135780 | REJECT | Complies with current verifications standards set by the community and followed by reviewers |
| 135781 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135782 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135783 | ADOPT | Moved to Carbon Twelve. Legal Entity of Marc Johnson |
| 135784 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135785 | REJECT | Complies with current verifications standards set by the community and followed by reviewers |
| 135786 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135787 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135788 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135792 | REJECT | Complies with current verifications standards set by the community and followed by reviewers |
| 135794 | REJECT | Complies with current verifications standards set by the community and followed by reviewers |
| 135795 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135796 | REJECT | Has active nodes |
| 135797 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135798 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135799 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135804 | REJECT | Has active nodes |
| 135805 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135806 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. Offboarded |
| 135822 | REJECT | Complies with current verifications standards set by the community and followed by reviewers |
| 135830 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |
| 135831 | ADOPT | No Self Declaration. No Nodes. |