thanks for making it more clear that not every token ledger has an index canister. I thought I covered this in following statement, but it’s definitely good to point this out again! 
This is a Oisy related question @peterparker
I’ve already shared your question with the team because it feels more like a product and vision question rather than a developer one.
Currently, both the OISY frontend and backend are controlled by the foundation, but they are now deployed using Orbit, which means a few selected members of the foundation must approve any deployment.
There is also a proposal to hand over a signer canister to the NNS (see post). The signer, for example, is used to derive the ETH address from the user’s principal.
This is the current status to my knowledge, and I’m not aware of the plans for the future. That’s a question for the foundation.
So chain key secures the wallet, like any other dapp on ICP
Thank you for your answer this is what I was looking for… !
The thing is… Its so basic that dapps should look in an automatic way for the index that it blows my mind away that after 4 years we still have this UX issues
1 Like
That’s a great example of an implementation detail that degrades user experience.
The solution is relatively simple: the ledger canister could expose a metadata entry that points to the index canister (which could be the same canister). We discussed this idea in the ICRC working group over a year ago; closing this loop and eliminating a major inconvenience in the user journey would be nice.
5 Likes
Not sure where the 4 years come from? ICRC-3 has only been voted into the standards and consequently implemented at the end of march this year.
Anyhow, regardless let’s remember that this topic is regarding Oisy and when it’ll be officially available. If you want a more clear timeline on the ICP ledger and the later ICRC standards, feel free to create a thread.
I’ll happily go into more details in another thread like their timeline, their relation with one another and the relevant working groups.
It took roughly 7 months for the ICRC-3 standard from inception to NNS voting. Please let me ask again, stay on the topic of this thread (Oisy). If you want to discuss this or another topic, create another thread 
Sure, but again, in my opinion, the issue is less about discovery and more about the fact that most meme coins on the IC do not spin up any Index canister.
Means OISY would either have to accept custom tokens without any transactions listed or displayed to users (which, in my opinion, isn’t top-notch UX neither, but none of my business) or be extended to support alternative aggregators, whether on-chain or off-chain.
Note: again, those requirements are already being tracked (both integration in OISY and Index discoverability question).
2 Likes
This has an easy answer.
Today, the IC dashboard doesn’t show any non SNS tokens in a clear format. @Dylan has let us know the dashboard will be updated to show ICRC tokens in the future. I imagine when that happens it’ll show the index then.
@Dylan do you have an ETA for when the dashboard will be updated?
@dfisher, we do plan to support non-ck/SNS tokens on the ICP Dashboard, but I don’t have an ETA of when.
This project hasn’t been started, so I can’t say whether the dashboard will display the index canister of a non-ck/SNS token token. The dashboard doesn’t currently use the index canister functionality, it indexes a token ledger using the ledger canister and its linked archive canisters. Because index canisters are not easily discoverable, there is no real incentive for the dashboard project to involve discovering them if they are not needed in order to support the token.
However, if something like @roman-kashitsyn described was implemented (“the ledger canister could expose a metadata entry that points to the index canister”), it would be trivial for the dashboard to display the index canister.
2 Likes
@gatsby_esp I understand your frustration, but let’s keep in mind that no other chain in the world has on-chain indexer APIs or any user-oriented APIs. They are using AWS to do these things, so the IC is far ahead of everything else.
9 Likes
This 
times
Any app utilizing ICRC standards to display user’s transactions would benefit from this. Would simplify lookup info.
Right now, even for Dfinity maintained tokens, you have SNS tokens that have this info in the root canister.
For ck and ICP tokens, there is no root, so this is a headache
Entering the bullrun and we haven’t solved this out. If I tell you what I thinking you would close my forum account.
This SIMPLE FEATURE WILL COST BILLIONS
Hi @skai8888, the ipfs version is not official, and we are not in any way affiliated with the content on it, but you can find our project on Github, using the link on our landing page.
Old Post (Summary): Possibly a false alarm, but I noticed a strange URL in the browser while using it.
Change Note: Likely a browser or user issue.
Conclusion: Oisy is an excellent new wallet!
Thank you, Stefan and Ishaaqziyan.
No traces of a phishing attempt were found after further investigation. It seems to have been a false alarm, likely caused on my end. I’ve deleted the previous messages. Thanks for your prompt response, and sorry for the inconvenience.
1 Like
it might help to automate or script the process if you’re doing it often
OISY now supports meme coins and other tokens without an Index canister. 
The feature has been released in version v0.9.4.
PS: I’m still personally not a fan of the UX 
4 Likes
Hi guys, do you know why still any application on ICP has integrated OISY wallet?
Not even ICPswap or Sonic… Is there a reason?