Updating the list of public subnets

Governance
12

Voted to adopt proposal #134334.

So while this proposal makes sense and it is so called “in line” with “adding additional application subnets” and it follows proposal# 132409 , I find the addition of the “Subnet Type” column in the summary very much appreciated, I still think that verifying this proposal is a bit complicated for new ppl.

Simply put:

  • using the IC Dashboard one can check for eg subnet 4zbus the TYPE (Application), number of Canisters(103) and State size(1.82 MiB).
  • a quick search for “subnet info” takes us to using just ic-admin
    ~$ ./ic-admin --nns-url=https://ic0.app get-subnet 4zbus-z2bmt-ilreg-xakz4-6tyre-hsqj4-slb4g-zjwqo-snjcc-iqphi-3qe gives quite a detailed list of info including in our example "subnet_type": "verified_application"
  • while actually using $ dre update-authorized-subnets does recreate propose-to-set-authorized-subnetworks to update the list including the payload so we can reproduce the proposal (ofc using dry-run and such should be known).

Anywho the TLDR of my rambling is including a short info/description on how to check/verify would be useful to have in the summary for future proposals, IMHO.

BTW the addition of 349c2a5 is great, really like that there is a check on how many VerifiedApplication subnets can pass.

Other thoughts:

They will be fine :wink:

2 Likes