I really appreciate the constructive discussion in this forum thread and I think that it is great that SNS key considerations (components on-chain vs off-chain, open source, voting power/decentralization) are brought up.
To the list of topics under discussion I would like to add the topic of security reviews. An earlier SNS forum post formulated this suggestion
- In general, it is considered to be best practice to conduct a security review including the fixing of risky findings. Guidance on security best practices is here .
- Hence, a project should explain to which extent security reviews are relevant for the dapp and what kind of security reviews have been conducted for the dapp if applicable.
@memecake Could you kindly elaborate on this? I assume that for a DEX the community might expect a high level of scrutiny ideally before the SNS launch.