Subnet Management - pzp6e (Fiduciary)

Governance NNS proposal discussions
, ,
122

Proposal 137090 Review | Malith H - CO.DELTA △

VOTE: NO :cross_mark:

TLDR:

This proposal removes 2 node(s) from Barcelona 1, HongKong 3 and adds 2 replacement node(s) in Antwerp, CABA 1.

Issue
Node zzuq4… has been active since 2024-10-18 by Proposal and seems to be active with no proper reason for removal from the subnet. I suggest that if it is removed from the subnet to improve decentralization stats, it should be mentioned on the proposal itself for proper historical record.

Subnet Details
Property Value
ID pzp6e…
Type application
Memory Usage 44.31 GB
Running Canisters 2923
Description N/A
Provider Changes
Removed Added
Carbon Twelve NODAO
Power Meta Corporation Mariano Stoll
Location Changes
Removed Added
Europe, Barcelona 1 Europe, Antwerp
Asia, HongKong 3 South America, CABA 1
Nodes Removed 2
Node ID Status Provider Data Center Location
pqcqa… UP Carbon Twelve es1 Barcelona 1
zzuq4… UP Power Meta Corporation hk3 HongKong 3
Nodes Added 2
Node ID Status Provider Data Center Location
qzhuj… UNASSIGNED NODAO an1 Antwerp
v27at… UNASSIGNED Mariano Stoll ar1 CABA 1

:warning: Issues:

:cross_mark: ISSUE: Node zzuq4… is not degraded or dead as claimed.

:white_check_mark: Passes:

:white_check_mark: Node pqcqa…: Remove from Subnet check passed.

:white_check_mark: Node zzuq4…: Remove from Subnet check passed.

:white_check_mark: Node qzhuj…: Replacement Status check passed.

:white_check_mark: Node qzhuj…: Not assigned to any subnet.

:white_check_mark: Node v27at…: Replacement Status check passed.

:white_check_mark: Node v27at…: Not assigned to any subnet.

You may wish to follow the CO.DELTA known neuron if you found this analysis helpful.

CO.DELTA

We’re a verifiably decentralised collective who review IC deltas (changes applied by NNS proposals). We follow a common code:

  • Look: We observe the details and context of NNS proposals

  • Test: We test and verify the claims made by those proposals

  • Automate: We automate as much as possible by building increasingly sophisticated tools that streamline and strengthen the reviewal process.

Every vote cast by CO.DELTA is the result of consensus among diligent, skilled and experienced team members acting independently. The CO.DELTA neuron follows the vote of D-QUORUM on NNS topics that the CO.DELTA team does not handle directly. You can therefore follow CO.DELTA on all topics and rely on the highest quality of vote.

1 Like
123

Proposal 137090 – Cyberowl | CodeGov

Vote: ADOPT

Summary:

Carbon Twelve is transitioning the operation of its eight ICP node machines to DEF—relocating four from Paris to join four in Barcelona and coordinating their removal from subnets, registry updates, and physical migration—to ensure uninterrupted service as C12 temporarily steps back but plans to return. Proposals [137088, 137089, 137090, 137091, 137092] are all related to this transition.

Summary

Health of each Node


// REMOVE
{
  "node_id": "pqcqa-fs3ly-y7v77-4faa5-jzuay-5i737-t3olr-w5o4y-7gkog-zqan3-7qe",
  "status": "Active",
  "location": "Barcelona 1",
  "provider": "Carbon Twelve",
  "subnet_id": "pzp6e-ekpqk-3c5x7-2h6so-njoeq-mt45d-h3h6c-q3mxf-vpeq5-fk5o7-yae"
}

{
  "node_id": "zzuq4-xiygt-ypkox-2tgdr-yvpzp-optye-xazeq-vnpw5-pata3-4jlle-wqe",
  "status": "Active",
  "location": "HongKong 3",
  "provider": "Power Meta Corporation",
  "subnet_id": "pzp6e-ekpqk-3c5x7-2h6so-njoeq-mt45d-h3h6c-q3mxf-vpeq5-fk5o7-yae"
}

// ADD
{
  "node_id": "qzhuj-nrvb7-pe3j4-qe2td-jfgco-xfkln-7zmcr-wopiq-pb3jk-dchd4-6qe",
  "status": "Awaiting",
  "location": "Antwerp",
  "provider": "NODAO",
  "subnet_id": "pzp6e-ekpqk-3c5x7-2h6so-njoeq-mt45d-h3h6c-q3mxf-vpeq5-fk5o7-yae"
}

{
  "node_id": "v27at-hedf7-4a2my-tboq6-escdm-77krt-2qfuq-zjptf-z2sbk-vd7zs-xae",
  "status": "Awaiting",
  "location": "CABA 1",
  "provider": "Mariano Stoll",
  "subnet_id": "pzp6e-ekpqk-3c5x7-2h6so-njoeq-mt45d-h3h6c-q3mxf-vpeq5-fk5o7-yae"
}

Are Power Meta Corporation and Carbon Twelve affiliated?

Decentralization & Topology Compliance

  • Node Providers:
    • Maximize the number of distinct providers
  • Data Centers:
    • Ensure maximum per DC is not exceeded
  • Data Center Owners
    • Verify compliance with ownership regulations
  • Countries:
    • Limit to no more than 3 nodes per country

Nakamoto-Coefficient Analysis

Excellent!

1 Like
124

Proposal to enable the vetKeys production key on the fiduciary subnet:

1 Like
125
1 Like
126
1 Like