Hi Philip,
Hope you’re doing well. I recall that you already registered a node provider principal as “Protocol16” a little while back through this proposal, which was executed successfully. The NP record is here. Any particular reason for registering an additional NP principal?
@SvenF @sat Any issue with an individual registering more than one NP principal?
@bitmoon I think the advice from @SvenF in this post gives the answer for the next step you need to take. Also worth getting feedback on the proposal details as the others suggested before formally submitting it. I agree the documentation is a bit confusing.
Thx for your comments. So what’s wrong on my proposal? Can you correct it ?
PROPOSAL 134365
Hello everyone, glad to read you all.
I am in the process of setup a node, in a DC not yet used in Lausanne. I am a natural person, and not a morale one.
Here’s the requested files:
Identity proof (SHA256: 208f4b388cde546486a926ce1c02cefd59933a765d49b9691fb300751754f0ec)
Hash sha256
(I blurred non relevant personal details.)
Self declaration (SHA256: e2599e672ac53a6a823f33176592014a416af805bd7bef159bd2b655a8be443a)
The hardware: (on which I am waiting on your approval before finalizing the order)
PowerEdge R7525 Server 1
*AMD EPYC 7343 3.2GHz, 16C/32T, 128M Cache (190W) 2
32GB RDIMM, 3200MT/s, Dual Rank 16Gb BASE x8*16
6.4TB Enterprise NVMe Mixed Use AG Drive U.2 Gen4 with carrier*5
*PowerEdge R7525 Motherboard, with 2 x 1Gb Onboard LOM (BCM5720)MLK V2 1
*Dual, Hot-plug, Redundant Power Supply (1+1) 1100W, Mixed Mode Titanium 2 will change for redundant 2800W
Intel X710 Dual Port 10GbE SFP+, OCP NIC 3.0*1
*Trusted Platform Module 2.0 V3 1
If anything is not clear, do not hesitate to liaise with me, I would be glad to amend. Many thanks
Apologies, the forum is blocking URL.
Summary: Register a node provider 'Yannick Endrion', in line with the announcement and discussion at https://forum.dfinity.org/t/new-node-provider-proposals/16643/547 . The self-declaration documentation is available at
https://e-y.io/downloads/Self_Declaration_Node_Yannick_Endrion.pdf with SHA256 hash e2599e672ac53a6a823f33176592014a416af805bd7bef159bd2b655a8be443a. The proof of identity is available at https://e-y.io/downloads/Identity_Proof_Yannick_Endrion.pdf with SHA256 hash 208f4b388cde546486a926ce1c02cefd59933a765d49b9691fb300751754f0ec
What do I need to correct ?
$ NEURON_ID=4749990804718866779
$ NODE_PROVIDER_PRINCIPAL=mjnyf-lzqq6-s7fzb-62rqm-xzvge-5oa26-humwp-dvwxp-jxxkf-hoel7-fqe
$ NODE_OPERATOR_PRINCIPAL=mhkja-j42tu-2kkvs-5rjub-vqkmh-cfpbh-dhtkx-xeqm6-6jgnu-aax76-eae
$ NODE_PROVIDER_NAME=“bitmoon”
$ NODE_ALLOWANCE=1
$ DC_ID=Li2
$ ./ic-admin
–nns-url https://ic0.app
-s ~/.config/dfx/identity/node-provider-hotkey/identity.pem
propose-to-add-node-operator
$NODE_PROVIDER_PRINCIPAL
–summary “Node provider ‘$NODE_PROVIDER_NAME’ is adding $NODE_ALLOWANCE nodes in the $DC_ID data center. The purchase of server has been done on 06.11.2023 is available at Bitmoon - Internet Computer Wiki with SHA256 78EB24E2FCD51BD33A93E118F04EA5DC9769C67B1BB21C15C199EA33C2FC1525”
–proposer $NEURON_ID
–node-operator-principal-id $NODE_OPERATOR_PRINCIPAL
–node-allowance $NODE_ALLOWANCE
–dc-id $DC_ID
Adding my statement for completeness.
Proposal #134343 Review — Roald | Aviate Labs
Voted: REJECT
Review:
Nodes from the same provider and in the same data center should consolidate under one operator ID.
Pointing to Louise’s post for further recommendation.
You might need to correct “Li2” to “li2” (lower case) in order to match the listing of your currently active node, however I’m not a node provider or a Dfinity team member so I’ll leave it to @SvenF and others to answer further.
Here below the update :
$ NEURON_ID=4749990804718866779
$ NODE_PROVIDER_PRINCIPAL=mjnyf-lzqq6-s7fzb-62rqm-xzvge-5oa26-humwp-dvwxp-jxxkf-hoel7-fqe
$ NODE_OPERATOR_PRINCIPAL=nvocp-jlbys-d44wi-od3pv-iws4n-2nll3-73hqk-koh72-3obvg-kt5v3-fae
$ NODE_PROVIDER_NAME=“bitmoon”
$ NODE_ALLOWANCE=1
$ DC_ID=li2
Thanks in advance for your confirmation before to post the proposal on the network
Voted to reject proposal 134358 as the proposal seeks to add a node provider but the same participant already has a currently registered node provider principal as shown here which was created through the successful execution of an earlier proposal. Removing the original node provider prior to adding the new one might be an option if @Protocol16 is wanting to change the name of the node provider.
Voted to reject proposal 134365 as the self-identity documents have not been added to the Internet Computer Wiki. These need to be uploaded to Node Provider Self Declarations - Internet Computer Wiki so that they will appear within the IC Wiki, as per the node provider self-declaration instructions here.
Still would be nice to have an answer.
Hi everyone,
Cross posting this information here for your visibility and as instructed here.
Let me know if you have any questions.
Rami
Apologies, I tried and it was under pending validation due my new account I guess, will add it back again.
Hello,
Thanks for your message.
When saving page:
May I kindly ask one of the admin to approve my wiki page / file upload ? so like that I can avoid having my proposal to be refused.
Thank you
There are still 3 days left, I’d be inclined to vote to adopt the proposal if in the meantime the files end up being uploaded, in order to avoid a resubmission. Unless Dfinity disagrees ? @SvenF
Update :
Voted to reject proposal 134358.
Voted to reject proposal 134365.
Since by now it is clear that documents must be uploaded and accepted by admins before the submission of the proposal.
Hi again, I added the 2 files under wiki. but both files uploads and files are still under pending validation . If you have moderator role and can accept the upload of my 2 files and the edition of my wiki page (with hash), I would be really thankful.
Many thanks
@louisevelayo @SvenF can I post the updated proposal ?
Hi @bitmoon,
Thanks for your patience. Please review this page. Note that your NEW_NODE_ALLOWANCE field should be 2 for the li2 DC. And you should be using the propose-to-update-node-operator-config command on ic-admin instead of proposing to add a node operator.
You should refer to the section about adjusting the node allowance in a data center.
Please ping me in Matrix (via the main IC Node Provider group) so we can troubleshoot further on there.
