@LightningLad91 @mechaquan @AndraGeorgescu
I can understand the comparison which you are drawing to the temperature check proposal. Indeed the decision on the temperature check proposal was not clear-cut and we had a discussion on whether this proposal would meet the criteria of our DFINITY voting guideline (as for example explained here by @diegop in an earlier post).
I guess the reality is that applying principles in practise always gives room for interpretation, and one could come up with arguments for and against a proposal, even when using the same principles.
And probably in hindsight, given the a big amount of controversy, which the voting by DFINITY on the temperature check proposal steered, it would have been better to vote no (while being open for further discussion at the same time).