SYBILing nodes! 😱 Exploiting IC Network... Community Attention Required!

[Lorimer]

Thanks @Sat

I’ve voted to adopt 2 and reject 1 (one which replaces a healthy node with an offline node). As noted by others, the proposals have already executed.

For those in the community that are interested in detailed reviews, I’ve provided links below. The rest of the CO.DELTA team will be posting their reviews and voting shortly.

Subnet Management - tdb26 (NNS)

Proposal 135664 Review | Lorimer - CO.DELTA △ VOTE: YES (note that this proposal has already executed) TLDR: Motivated by unsubstantiated concerns of collusion risk. Note that while the motion mentions me and links to a post that I created - I was not personally responsible for the primary claims in this motion. This Subnet Membership proposal errs on the side of caution by moving a few of the mentioned NPs out of the NNS subnet while further discussion takes place. It’s unclear why an Allusion…

Subnet Management - pzp6e (Fiduciary)

Proposal 135665 Review | Lorimer - CO.DELTA △ VOTE: NO (note that this proposal has already executed) TLDR: One of the nodes being added to this subnet is actually offline. I’m not sure if it was online when the proposal was raised. It therefore objectively worsens the health of the subnet. This proposal was motivated by unsubstantiated concerns of collusion risk. Note that while the motion mentions me and links to a post that I created - I was not personally responsible for the primary claims…

Subnet Management - uzr34 (II)

Proposal 135666 Review | Lorimer - CO.DELTA △ VOTE: YES (note that this proposal has already executed) TLDR: This proposal was motivated by unsubstantiated concerns of collusion risk. Note that while the motion mentions me and links to a post that I created - I was not personally responsible for the primary claims in this motion . This Subnet Membership proposal errs on the side of caution by moving a few of the mentioned NPs out of the II subnet while further discussion takes place. 4 healthy…

---

For those in the community that are looking to follow a decentralised neuron that’s also backed by a team that put the work in to review these sorts of technical proposals, consider following CO.DELTA △. We’re almost finished with testing and finalising the controller relationship between the canisters to enforce decentralisation.