Subnet Management - General Discussion

Governance NNS proposal discussions
, ,
13

As per our discussion here: Subnet Management Discussion, using the ‘Change Subnet Membership’ proposal requires replacing node IDs, which I believe should be decided by Dfinity or an independent reviewer, not by NPs.

For reference based on this proposal, the parameters might look like this:

./ic-admin --nns-url https://ic0.app \
    propose-to-change-subnet-membership \
    --summary "" \
    --proposer <NEURON_ID> \
    --subnet-id <SUBNET_ID> \
    --node_ids_add <NODE_ID_TO_ADD> \
    --node_ids_remove <NODE_ID_TO_REMOVE>

I disagree that NPs should decide on replacement nodes.

The simple steps for redeploying a node should be:

  1. Show your intent on the appropriate subnet forum post.
  2. Once agreed, submit a proposal to either remove or swap the node based on the discussion.
  3. After approval on the NNS, disconnect the nodes and redeploy.

@Lorimer If you can kindly let me know which nodes I can use to replace that also would be great

2 Likes