Subnet Management - uzr34 (II)

:heart_eyes:

Thanks Sat :pray:


Proposal 132225

TLDR: I’ve adopted this proposal :heart_on_fire: it brings this subnet inline with the IC target topology! 4 removed nodes replaced with nodes in Israel, South Africa, Croatia and Sri Lanka to improve decentralisation coefficients.

Decentralisation Stats

Subnet node distance stats (distance between any 2 nodes in the subnet) β†’

Smallest Distance Average Distance Largest Distance
EXISTING 0 km 8050.519 km 19448.574 km
PROPOSED 0 km 7993.733 km (-0.7%) 19448.574 km

This proposal ever so slightly reduces decentralisation considered purely in terms of geographic distance (and therefore there’s a slight theoretical reduction in localised disaster resilience).

Subnet characteristic counts β†’

Continents Countries Data Centers Owners Node Providers
EXISTING 5 21 28 26 28
PROPOSED 5 23 (+8.7%) 28 28 (+7.1%) 28

This proposal significantly improves decentralisation in terms of jurisdiction diversity and data center owner diversity. :+1:

Largest number of nodes with the same characteristic (e.g. continent, country, data center, etc.) β†’

Continent Country Data Center Owner Node Provider
EXISTING 10 5 1 2 1
PROPOSED 9 (-10%) 3 (-40%) 1 1 (-50%) 1

See here for acceptable limits β†’ Motion 132136. After this proposal is executed this subnet will be meeting the IC target topology decentralisation coefficients! :tada:

The above subnet information is illustrated below, followed by a node reference table:

Map Description
  • Red marker represents a removed node (transparent center for overlap visibility)
  • Green marker represents an added node
  • Blue marker represents an unchanged node
  • Highlighted patches represent the country the above nodes sit within (red if the country is removed, green if added, otherwise grey)
  • Light grey markers with yellow borders are examples of unassigned nodes that would be viable candidates for joining the subnet according to formal decentralisation coefficients (so this proposal can be viewed in the context of alternative solutions that are not being used)

Table
Continent Country Data Center Owner Node Provider Node Status
--- Americas Costa Rica San JosΓ© 1 (cr1) Navegalo GeoNodes LLC os2wv-dchv6-fjwdg-nichf-3cra6-wccb3-57glq-xqgen-zwobp-aonve-lqe UP
--- Europe Germany Frankfurt 2 (fr2) Equinix Virtual Hive Ltd ysjs7-fe67q-k7pxe-g4puk-d5z7p-xrtg2-xqcmy-pmpoa-7bcfu-pmlqy-rae UP
--- Americas United States of America (the) Atlanta (at1) Flexential BLP22, LLC v6caw-kf4b4-j22f5-pqsvj-hg7dj-wx4xx-y7urh-eixmh-hnvz7-hoe2v-jae UP
--- Americas United States of America (the) Houston (hu1) TRG 43rd Big Idea Films ham46-r7u4j-yoyrk-mrnxu-utzq3-c37he-vcns2-gc5yg-jxyv5-mvlhc-gae UP
+++ Europe Croatia Zagreb 1 (zg1) Anonstake Anonstake q3vac-kcwo2-ruiht-nflb7-ifoev-vkjcw-quybi-ugvgn-pqfwp-jntxi-dqe UNASSIGNED
+++ Asia Israel Tel Aviv 1 (tv1) Interhost GeoNodes LLC rfkza-27bii-6jan4-u4zll-lkvmz-snmao-irmlj-arpdd-kyxrg-xnq3a-7ae UNASSIGNED
+++ Asia Sri Lanka Colombo 1 (cm1) OrionStellar Geodd Pvt Ltd suty3-goyd2-t6ngb-dsgzv-vkvt6-w2x4t-lioxl-2xsaa-ztaly-y2ov2-hae UNASSIGNED
+++ Africa South Africa Cape Town 2 (ct2) Teraco Kontrapunt (Pty) Ltd kgo2t-vidyw-yw2g5-pqwrt-nr227-rbq2o-pog27-zarc2-dfrlw-vvjge-4qe UNASSIGNED
Americas Argentina CABA 1 (ar1) SyT - Servicios y Telecomunicaciones S.A. Mariano Stoll v27at-hedf7-4a2my-tboq6-escdm-77krt-2qfuq-zjptf-z2sbk-vd7zs-xae UP
Oceania Australia Queensland 1 (sc1) NEXTDC ANYPOINT PTY LTD zjiki-pzvnv-m4rnn-fodt3-poon4-uldx7-d3wkq-gptsu-g2mjs-boi35-3qe UP
Europe Belgium Antwerp (an1) Datacenter United Allusion xu2zg-nns7x-z67l6-foa5w-yc4ek-addku-g2hqg-c3jdg-wabdu-5ouaw-yae UP
Americas Canada Fremont (fm1) Hurricane Electric Boolean Bit, LLC z4jw5-v4ee6-aa7gr-5axkc-4ocjy-v5vv5-inwc6-ma4hw-mb7jv-3skxy-eqe UP
Americas Canada Toronto (to1) Cyxtera Blockchain Development Labs x3cey-uerdd-53a7n-d45e2-gjsnd-airg5-nrs5i-4xujk-c5ynl-4pie6-yqe UP
Europe Switzerland Zurich 3 (zh3) Nine.Ch Tomahawk.vc v2pkj-vpsow-fp24q-zqwfj-p3nek-m52xz-oz6ra-blmra-73voj-jvwb5-gae UP
Asia China HongKong 1 (hk1) Unicom Pindar Technology Limited w4ri3-ytfnq-jg3z3-qseka-se4xe-b2fl2-km766-ruzwd-riw72-6bifs-4ae UP
Americas Costa Rica Bogota 1 (bg1) EdgeUno Geeta Kalwani aajth-ndp7x-ro5ok-yikyd-4i7xn-5k5ki-e3d37-hh4gn-s4opz-bnzxf-4qe UP
Europe Czechia South Moravian Region 1 (bn1) Master Internet Maksym Ishchenko zgtrt-4vlgr-pbytl-t2yqq-qf4nk-wyoos-vrfpu-hxqcw-tcnfu-73kjb-pae UP
Europe Spain Madrid 1 (ma1) Ginernet Ivanov Oleksandr yi6r6-u4kax-jphcr-jcqr5-t3zpm-gmp3b-2hiew-iinpf-sgjos-eabha-aqe UP
Europe Estonia Tallinn 2 (ta2) Telia DC Artem Horodyskyi zgeaf-fcq4e-fcnht-g7mpg-sb7ff-r6awk-zvkwp-gkloc-rr6jl-ghsse-mqe UP
Asia Georgia Tbilisi 1 (tb1) Cloud9 George Bassadone uouxk-c246i-dgxzd-ql3a5-koofn-mclrv-toplo-bg76d-l4dzk-ngb3c-nae UP
Asia India New Delhi 1 (nd1) Marvelous Web3 DC Marvelous Web3 67t6p-i4h3c-msv6p-kmbmm-rr6gj-z3nix-d6lo2-mq3q4-3h6rb-lwkbc-lae UP
Asia India Panvel 2 (pl2) Yotta Krishna Enterprises dyycg-wc45f-jwks2-abddo-m3n5r-o5kxy-g5xhm-7ve4u-3tlk7-i7xec-oae UP
Asia Japan Tokyo (ty1) Equinix Starbase go5zz-xs6yg-mylwl-v7uob-7bg4b-wjzhe-vmrwe-uy7mz-ckaz2-idm33-rqe UP
Asia Korea (the Republic of) Seoul 2 (kr2) Gasan Web3game wjwzb-q3ogf-fi3po-kf6y6-wzuuj-3ac3m-kjvab-fufsm-z2skq-kthkx-xae UP
Europe Poland Warszawa 2 (wa2) Central Tower DC Bohatyrov Volodymyr mswad-oq7wj-5r4yy-b5qoy-cmv7z-wzfb3-ktn6l-rcnrz-mni2f-lsys6-wqe UP
Asia Singapore Singapore 2 (sg2) Telin OneSixtyTwo Digital Capital qp3lh-25yxy-dlk4t-ay73d-frr4t-3kmi5-35kqg-3vvbq-26qhh-6xrdr-oqe UP
Europe Slovenia Ljubljana (lj1) Posita.si Fractal Labs AG 6adxp-p7u63-xsdtk-lo6oc-vpqmi-44hgt-yv652-cbm5p-mssge-wsrz6-oqe UP
Europe Sweden Stockholm 1 (sh1) Digital Realty DFINITY Operations SA vgfnl-4phvh-44pk3-yshmp-ckwz3-qnzob-l5wnj-pqn2j-vv5jh-3oewk-xqe UP
Americas United States of America (the) Chicago 3 (ch3) CyrusOne MI Servers gtfa3-saq3t-ymlel-lsf6d-ans7b-cr45x-xg5np-xbxyt-nxfrt-iynyy-5qe UP
Americas United States of America (the) Orlando (or1) Datasite Giant Leaf, LLC z5a4h-43szy-vvp4j-xorii-l6yma-4iyzt-7o3ry-frvqe-azkit-5iag2-rqe UP
Americas United States of America (the) Panama City 1 (pc1) Navegalo Bianca-Martina Rohner y7bml-csbq7-euzyf-njmvm-qfftp-iy7lc-wisaq-jlmul-sdo7p-7lkx4-3ae UP
Africa South Africa Gauteng 2 (jb2) Africa Data Centres Karel Frank xav3a-kdo3a-2rgbg-o6vnk-clat5-bcc7w-vmnej-z55rx-mfx26-7xugo-tqe UP

Known Neurons to follow if you're too busy to keep on top of things like this

If you found this analysis helpful and would like to follow the vote of the LORIMER known neuron in the future, consider configuring LORIMER as a followee for the Subnet Management topic.

Other good neurons to follow:

  • Synapse (Synapse follows the LORIMER and CodeGov known neurons for Subnet Management, and is a generally well informed known neuron to follow on numerous other topics)

  • CodeGov (will soon be committed to actively reviewing and voting on Subnet Management proposals based on those reviews, and is well informed on numerous other technical topics)

  • WaterNeuron (the WaterNeuron DAO frequently discuss proposals like this in order to vote responsibly based on DAO consensus)

4 Likes